Numero Cinco
New Member
venturaguy49 said:thusly, qualifying(in a way) as a new topic. both groups, while obviously different in most respects, had one common factor that identified them: harmony From the beginning, T.J.B. used harmony parts that had a distinctively 'Mex' quality, but that didn't always remain true, as the chart for "Lollipops & Roses" is basically a 'swing arrangement, with harmony that's right out of the Big Band Era(I'm a huge swing fan, and so I've listened to plenty of it.) "Lollopops" is clearly a 'little big band', with scarcely any Mex feel about it. . . . With instrumental aggregations, such boundaries are non-existant, and the Tijuana Brass is a shining example of proper harmony. Listen carefully to their recordings, and what one hears is not a formulized approach to harmony, but one that fluctuates consistently. One moment it's solo, then 1st and 3rd, then unison of 1st, and so forth. That's interesting to me. Made for intriquing records.
As for just when, and what album qualifies as T.J.B. proper, it's hard to say, and so I'll just observe, that the thing that made them(in my opinion) so cool, was that way of presenting melodies . . . THAT, to my sensibilities, is what the Tijuana Brass was all about: playing imaginative arrangements that just naturally piqued ones interest. That was a quality that just MADE the Brass special, and it's one that is present on every album that they issued. Everyone has their favorites, but in the end, it was Herb Alpert's way with a song, combined with superb fellow players that made for such a fascinating outfit.
Very perceptive comments, especially those about the Beatles. Some further reflections:
On a song like "Lollipops and Roses," I entirely agree that it shows Big Band's influence on Herb. Offhand, I can't think of a better example than the one you've picked. The thing that places a TJB stamp on "Lollipops," thus differentiating it from most Big Band swing, is the instrumentation. Strip out the marimbas and maracas, and it's straight swing. Reinsert them, and it's TJB.
On Herb's constant experimentation with harmony, see Lost Treasures's alternative take of "Up Cherry Street." It begins with trumpets harmonized in thirds, and stays that way with the exception of the last run-through before the key-change. In the version on You Smile, the harmony isn't introduced until after the bridge is first played.
As my previous posts indicate, I stand second to none in admiration for Mr. A.'s way to make a song his own. While chauffering a car full of fifty- and sixty-somethings the other day, I put Lost Treasures into my player and skipped immediately to "Happy Hour." No one had heard the track before, but everyone immediately recognized the artist. "That's Herb Alpert."