Portlander
Well-Known Member
Never claimed that Hall & Oates were superior to the Carpenters. I do feel that they have become more iconic over the years which is what the article was about. If Karen was still with us, myself and others might have a different perspective. To say that my musical judgement needs to be reconsidered seems to be a little harsh. If I remember correctly, the Rolling Stone Magazine was not friendly to either of them during the height of their popularity.
I "love" the Carpenters and they have been my favorite since the age of 13 and remain so 50 years later. I "like" Hall & Oates along with many other artists and I've always tried to be objective when it comes to judging music, automobiles and sports. I agree with Yamaguchi when it comes to the international success between the two duos and realize the amazing impact the Carpenters have had abroad and they have an edge in overall record sales.
Hall & Oates were relevant during both decades (70's and 80's) and surpassed the Carpenters in most Top 40 categories with the exception of the Adult Contemporary charts. Carpenters had a #8 Counrty hit, H&O had a #1 R&B hit. Overall success in the United States to date would lean towards H&O in my opinion. They are still actively touring and selling out mid size venues around the country and "Daryl's House" brought Daryl a new level of respect among musicians along with induction into the RRHOF for the duo.
I "love" the Carpenters and they have been my favorite since the age of 13 and remain so 50 years later. I "like" Hall & Oates along with many other artists and I've always tried to be objective when it comes to judging music, automobiles and sports. I agree with Yamaguchi when it comes to the international success between the two duos and realize the amazing impact the Carpenters have had abroad and they have an edge in overall record sales.
Hall & Oates were relevant during both decades (70's and 80's) and surpassed the Carpenters in most Top 40 categories with the exception of the Adult Contemporary charts. Carpenters had a #8 Counrty hit, H&O had a #1 R&B hit. Overall success in the United States to date would lean towards H&O in my opinion. They are still actively touring and selling out mid size venues around the country and "Daryl's House" brought Daryl a new level of respect among musicians along with induction into the RRHOF for the duo.