GaryAlan
Well-Known Member
MustHearThisAlbum, you are not alone (nice analysis, by the way ! ),
as I feel that Grein misses too many other elements ( in Carpenters' decline) .
Although, I never much believed Weintraub's assessment, either. ( e.g., 'an artists' natural decline').
Still, I wonder if releasing-- as singles--lightweight tunes such as Sing and Please Mr. Postman,
instead of, say, This Masquerade, was not a poor choice of direction to proceed.
Richard Carpenter sought accolades from his arranging and production duties, yet,
certain singles simply do not represent the depth he is capable of in Carpenters' music.
(And, yet, he did receive a Best Instrumental Arrangement nomination for Sing !).
Album cuts show much more depth than some of those singles.
(And, I actually still cringe at the releasing of It's Going To Take Some Time, as a single---
it shows an early weakness, IMHO).
as I feel that Grein misses too many other elements ( in Carpenters' decline) .
Although, I never much believed Weintraub's assessment, either. ( e.g., 'an artists' natural decline').
Still, I wonder if releasing-- as singles--lightweight tunes such as Sing and Please Mr. Postman,
instead of, say, This Masquerade, was not a poor choice of direction to proceed.
Richard Carpenter sought accolades from his arranging and production duties, yet,
certain singles simply do not represent the depth he is capable of in Carpenters' music.
(And, yet, he did receive a Best Instrumental Arrangement nomination for Sing !).
Album cuts show much more depth than some of those singles.
(And, I actually still cringe at the releasing of It's Going To Take Some Time, as a single---
it shows an early weakness, IMHO).